
Carol is another immaculately crafted piece of cinema from filmmaker Todd Haynes (I’m Not There, Safe, Velvet Goldmine), featuring two splendid performances from Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara, with an attention to aesthetic detail that will make lovers of costumes and production design and cinematography drool with delight. Shot in gauzy, smoky 16 mm film by the tremendous cameraman Ed Lachman, Carol feels like the fossilized remains of people’s tragically pained lives from over 60 years ago, with the sensitive screenplay by Phyllis Nagy hitting all of the appropriate notes of melancholy love and unstoppable yet forbidden passion. Based on the Patricia Highsmith novel The Price of Salt, the film tracks the love affair between a married woman (Blanchett) and her younger flame (Mara), the film paints a sad and incredibly serious account of two people who can’t resist temptation, even if they know that it’ll be nearly impossible to have exactly what it is that they want. Kyle Chandler, yet again, impresses in a small but pivotal role as Blanchett’s scorned and dismayed husband, and Sarah Paulson, as usual, steals all of the chances afforded to her by the intelligent, quietly powerful screenplay. It’s possible that Blanchett and Mara may be a bit mismatched for each other in this film; while I was thoroughly engaged all throughout, I was kept at a curiously slight remove on an emotional level. It might have been due to the overwhelming sense of craft that Haynes was displaying, or because of how the film kept a very level head about itself, never giving into cheap histrionics or sensationalistic speechifying.
This is a slow-burn drama, lingering long in the memory, a film made with tremendous care in all departments, and tackling subject matter that isn’t necessarily entertaining so much as it is enlightening. Mara was absolutely sensational, doing tons of emoting with her exceedingly expressive face (those eyes are extra intense…), and punctuating each line of dialogue with pointed eloquence. It’s no surprise that she took top honors at the Cannes Film Festival for this restrained, deeply internal performance. Blanchett, one of our most dramatic of actresses, sunk her teeth into a role that she seemed destined to inhabit, and while I’ve liked some of her other performances a bit more, there’s no denying her extreme skill as an performer; she totally owned this role with all her might. And it’s remarkable to note how she can effortlessly swing back and forth between the stage and screen, never losing sight of the specific ways that both mediums can create and emotional stir. The appropriate but repetitious musical score hangs in the air like a harbinger of emotional doom, giving off a tentative vibe in some scenes, and swooning with romanticism in some key spots. Carol feels like a thematic companion piece to Haynes’ excellent 2002 film Far From Heaven, which his homage to Douglas Sirk melodramas and featured an anguished performance from Dennis Quaid as a man struggling with his closeted homosexuality. Haynes is a socially conscious filmmaker interested in the human condition with each of his projects, and I could only hope to see more work from him in the near future, as it seems way too long in between projects for this unique cinematic voice.

























